The Urban vs. Rural Dilemma in Open-World Games: What GTA 6 Needs to Get Right

For GTA 6 to truly stand out, it must master the art of blending urban and rural environments in a way that feels natural, immersive, and rewarding.

When evaluating open-world games, one crucial factor that often comes to mind is just how "open" the world actually is. But the definition of "open" can vary depending on the type of game and its setting. U4GM's gta buy cheap 5 modded accounts allow players to bypass the extensive grind required to accumulate in-game money. Use coupon code "allen" to get 5% off at U4GM. For example, one major frustration I had with Cyberpunk 2077's Night City was the abundance of fake, inaccessible buildings. As we eagerly await the release of GTA 6, I’m hoping Rockstar can address this issue and truly set the bar for urban open-world games.

Urban vs. Rural Open-World Games

Open-world games set in rural environments, such as Breath of the Wild or The Witcher 3, offer vast freedom to explore natural landscapes, discover hidden gems, and engage in spontaneous quests. Players can traverse hills, mountains, forests, and caves, all while finding interesting surprises along the way. These worlds often reward exploration, offering players wide open spaces to get lost in.

However, the dynamics shift when we move into urban open-world settings. In cities, the terrain is defined by streets, buildings, and infrastructure. While the freedom to roam the streets is still present, a major question arises: Can you enter and explore these buildings? This is becoming a make-or-break issue for many players, especially in modern open-world games.

GTA's Evolution: From Vice City to GTA 5

As GTA has evolved over the years, its open-world designs have improved significantly, especially when it comes to the number of buildings you can enter and explore. GTA Vice City had a rather limited selection of interiors, restricted mostly to buildings required for the progression of the main story. By GTA 5, Rockstar had expanded this concept considerably, allowing players to explore a variety of structures, such as shops, restaurants, gyms, underground tunnels, and more. It wasn't just about the size of the world, but the density of interesting, explorable content within it.

In games of such vast scale, providing detailed interiors can be a monumental task, but Rockstar has consistently excelled at balancing both breadth and density. Red Dead Redemption 2 took a similar approach with fewer buildings than GTA, but still managed to pack the Old West with highly detailed structures such as saloons and movie theaters, inviting players to relax and immerse themselves in the world.

The Importance of Accessible Urban Spaces

Despite the improvements made in GTA 5 and Red Dead Redemption 2, there is still room for growth. As GTA 6 approaches, one of the biggest requests from players is the inclusion of even more buildings to enter and explore. While open-world games with rural settings (like Tears of the Kingdom or Horizon Forbidden West) often allow for expansive landscapes to be explored, the urban open-world experience requires much more attention to detail in terms of individual spaces. In rural games, players are generally content with traversing wide fields, forests, and caves. The interaction with these spaces is more about the overall experience rather than the nitty-gritty of every single object in the world.

However, in urban environments, players expect buildings to be accessible and interactive on a much deeper level. When a game fails to deliver on this expectation, it can be a huge setback. This was my main issue with Cyberpunk 2077 at launch. Despite a visually impressive world, the inability to enter most buildings became a major obstacle to exploration. Even though Phantom Liberty improved many aspects of the game, it couldn’t fix this fundamental problem.

Can GTA 6 Deliver?

Looking ahead to GTA 6, there's a great deal of hope that it will overcome the shortcomings of Cyberpunk 2077 and deliver a truly immersive urban open world. The first trailer for the game shows an impressively dense Vice City, packed with things to do and places to explore. Rockstar doesn’t need to reinvent the wheel; they simply need to provide the key to the city—unlocking a world filled with accessible, meaningful spaces for players to enjoy.

As we await GTA 6's release, the expectation is clear: urban open-world games must deliver not just size, but true interactivity and density, with an emphasis on exploration that keeps players engaged for hours on end. Only then will the open-world formula reach its full potential, especially in a city as iconic as Vice City.


allen ava

211 Blog posts

Comments